Why Does Ketchup Get Stuck? The Physics of Yield Stress
Ketchup is a soft solid that will not flow below about 45 pascals of stress, then thins a thousandfold. Why it sticks, why it gushes and where to tap.
Table of Contents
You turn the glass bottle over the fries. Nothing. You tilt it further, shake it, glare at it. Still nothing. Then you give it one good thump and half the bottle lands on your plate at once. In the late 1970s Heinz even set its adverts to Carly Simon’s “Anticipation”.
That all-or-nothing behaviour is not bad luck. It is the signature of a material that is a solid when left alone and a runny liquid once pushed hard enough, a textbook case for rheology, the science of how things flow.
A Sauce That Is Technically a Solid
Ketchup is a suspension: crushed tomato solids, often boosted by starches or gums such as xanthan, packed into a watery liquid of vinegar and sugar. The particles are crowded enough to touch, forming a loose, continuous network through the whole bottle. As University of Melbourne engineer Anthony Stickland puts it, tomato sauce “prefers to be in the bottle because it is technically a solid, not a liquid.”
That network gives ketchup a yield stress, τ_y: a threshold of shear stress below which it bends a little and springs back, like jelly, instead of flowing. In 2009 Zdeňka Panovská, Petr Štern and colleagues in Prague measured 20 ketchups bought in supermarkets, using a vane rotor that avoids slipping on the sample. Their static yield stresses ranged from 25 to 65 pascals, with a mean of 45 Pa.
Forty-five pascals is tiny next to atmospheric pressure, about 100,000 Pa, but plenty to hold a dollop together. Picture a layer of ketchup of thickness h on a vertical wall. Its weight pulls down with a stress of about ρgh at the wall, and it stays put as long as that is less than τ_y. With a density ρ of about 1,100 kg/m³, the layer can be roughly τ_y/ρg ≈ 4 mm thick before it starts to slide. That is why ketchup sits in a neat blob on a burger while water would run straight off.
Viscosity That Depends on How Hard You Push
Isaac Newton’s rule for fluids is simple: shear stress is proportional to shear rate, τ = ηγ̇, where the shear rate γ̇ measures how fast neighbouring layers slide past one another and η is the viscosity. Water has η ≈ 0.001 Pa·s, honey something like 10 Pa·s, and both keep that value however fast you stir, as our guide to why honey flows slowly explains.
Ketchup has no single viscosity. In 1916 Eugene Bingham at the US Bureau of Standards described suspensions that only flow above a threshold, writing τ = τ_y + η_pγ̇ for stresses beyond the yield point. A decade later Winslow Herschel and Ronald Bulkley generalised this to τ = τ_y + Kγ̇ⁿ, where K is a consistency and n a flow index. With n below 1 the material is shear-thinning: the faster it flows, the less it resists. Panovská’s team found that this Herschel–Bulkley form fitted their ketchups well.
Rheologists summarise it with an apparent viscosity, η = τ/γ̇, the viscosity a Newtonian fluid would need to give the same stress at that shear rate. For ketchup it is effectively infinite below the yield stress and then falls steeply. With illustrative values τ_y = 45 Pa, K = 10 Pa·sⁿ and n = 0.4, it drops from several thousand pascal-seconds at a slow creep to below 0.1 Pa·s at the shear rates of a fast pour, a fall of well over a thousandfold. Microscopically, the particle network is torn apart and the fragments line up with the flow.
Ketchup also has memory, called thixotropy. In Panovská’s tests a large strain made its elastic moduli collapse, and a few minutes after the strain stopped they were back at their starting values. That is why a bottle you just shook pours easily, and the same bottle sticks again by the end of the meal.
Why You Tap the Neck
Turn the bottle upside down and the ketchup that matters is the plug in the neck, which has to move first. In a pipe, the shear stress in a flowing material is zero on the axis and grows linearly towards the wall, τ(r) = τ_w·r/R, so a yield-stress fluid always fails first against the glass. What comes out is a nearly solid core of ketchup sliding on a thin, sheared skin, a pattern called plug flow.
You can estimate what gravity alone delivers. The weight of a plug of radius R and length L is ρgπR²L, and it is resisted by the wall stress acting over the area 2πRL, so τ_w = ρgR/2, independent of how long the plug is. For a neck about 2 cm across, R = 1 cm and τ_w ≈ 1,100 × 9.8 × 0.01 / 2 ≈ 54 Pa. That is right in the range of measured yield stresses, which is why an upturned bottle sometimes creeps out on its own and sometimes sits there indefinitely. A sharp tap briefly multiplies the effective g by the acceleration of the jolt, pushing the wall stress well past τ_y.
Where to tap? A Heinz spokesperson told the Mirror in 2016 that the answer is the raised 57 on the neck of the glass bottle, adding that only 11 per cent of people knew it. The physics fits: the jolt arrives right where the plug has to yield. Stickland’s routine is complementary: shake first with the lid on to remix, hold the bottle at about 45 degrees, and give gentle but firm taps on the base, increasing them until the sauce just moves. Because ketchup thins as it flows, a tap that is too strong does not give you a little more. It gives you a flood.
The glass helps too, in a slippery way. Particles cannot pack flat against a smooth wall, so a suspension develops a thin layer next to it that is depleted of particles and much runnier than the bulk. Howard Barnes reviewed this wall slip in 1995 as a headache for viscosity measurements. In a bottle the same layer acts as a lubricant, so the plug slides rather than shears, much as a thin film of water changes the friction between two solid surfaces.
Cornstarch: The Fluid That Fights Back
Mix cornstarch with roughly half its volume of water and you get the mirror image of ketchup. Stir slowly and a spoon glides through; jab it and the surface turns hard and cracks. This is shear thickening, flow index n above 1 in the language of Herschel and Bulkley, and in dense suspensions it can be so abrupt that the viscosity jumps by orders of magnitude.
Eric Brown and Heinrich Jaeger’s 2014 review in Reports on Progress in Physics traces this to the same physics that jams granular materials. Pushed slowly, the grains slide past one another on films of water. Pushed fast, they are forced into frictional contact and lock into chains that span the container and push back against the walls, the same jamming that keeps sand in an hourglass from simply pouring like water.
That explains a spoon, but not a person running across a pool of the stuff: the stresses measured in steady shear are far too small. In 2012 Scott Waitukaitis and Jaeger, at the University of Chicago, dropped an aluminium rod into a cornstarch suspension and followed it with high-speed video, embedded force sensors and X-ray imaging. They found that each impact launched a solidification front, turning the loose particles beneath the rod into a rapidly growing jammed region. The rod was effectively ramming an ever-growing solid mass, and the momentum that mass absorbs provides the force that supports a running foot. Stop, and the solid melts back into liquid, and you sink.
Paint, Toothpaste, Blood and Quicksand
Toothpaste is a yield-stress material: it holds its shape on the brush, then flows when you squeeze the tube. Mayonnaise is an emulsion of oil droplets packed so tightly that they deform against one another, giving it a yield stress strong enough to stand in peaks. Good paint is shear-thinning and thixotropic, so it spreads easily under the brush and then thickens again on the wall before it can run.
Your own blood is shear-thinning. At low shear rates red blood cells stack into loose columns called rouleaux, which break apart in faster flow, as described in our piece on how blood moves through the body. And quicksand behaves like a dangerous cousin of ketchup: at rest it holds weight like a solid, but a disturbance liquefies it, and once grains settle around a trapped leg it becomes extremely hard to pull free.
Let the Bottle Do the Work
Engineers eventually stopped fighting the yield stress and started using it. The squeeze bottle, introduced for ketchup in 1983, lets your hand supply the stress directly. The upside-down bottle followed in the early 2000s, so the sauce already rests against the outlet. Between squeezes, a valve in the cap and the yield stress, once the whole problem, together keep the sauce from dripping out.
So the stubborn bottle is not failing to pour a liquid. It is holding a solid that becomes a liquid on demand, and a well-aimed tap at the neck is just enough stress, delivered in the right place.
Sources
- Textural and flavour characteristics of commercial tomato ketchups, Z. Panovská, P. Štern, A. Váchová, D. Lukešová and J. Pokorný, Czech Journal of Food Sciences 27, 165–170 (2009): yield stress of 20 commercial ketchups (25–65 Pa, mean 45 Pa), Herschel–Bulkley fits, thixotropic recovery
- Getting tomato sauce out of the bottle – minus the mess, N. Hannink, University of Melbourne Pursuit (2016): Anthony Stickland on ketchup as a yield-stress fluid and how to pour it
- Heinz revealed the 1 trick you need to get ketchup out of its glass bottles, Business Insider (2016), reporting the Heinz spokesperson’s advice to the Mirror to tap the 57
- What’s the secret to pouring ketchup? Know your physics, NPR The Salt (2014): squeeze bottle in 1983, the upside-down bottle, and the “Anticipation” campaign
- An investigation of the laws of plastic flow, E. C. Bingham, Bulletin of the Bureau of Standards 13, 309–353 (1916): the Bingham plastic model
- A review of the slip (wall depletion) of polymer solutions, emulsions and particle suspensions in viscometers: its cause, character, and cure, H. A. Barnes, Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics 56, 221–251 (1995)
- Shear thickening in concentrated suspensions: phenomenology, mechanisms and relations to jamming, E. Brown and H. M. Jaeger, Reports on Progress in Physics 77, 046602 (2014)
- Impact-activated solidification of dense suspensions via dynamic jamming fronts, S. R. Waitukaitis and H. M. Jaeger, Nature 487, 205–209 (2012)
- A Handbook of Elementary Rheology, H. A. Barnes, University of Wales Institute of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics, Aberystwyth (2000): yield stress, shear thinning, thixotropy and the Herschel–Bulkley model
- Non-Newtonian Flow and Applied Rheology, 2nd edition, R. P. Chhabra and J. F. Richardson, Butterworth-Heinemann (2008): plug flow of yield-stress fluids in pipes
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does ketchup get stuck in the bottle?
Ketchup gets stuck because at rest it is not really a liquid but a soft solid. It is a dense suspension of crushed tomato solids, pulp and thickeners in a watery liquid, and those particles touch one another to form a continuous network. The network gives ketchup a yield stress: below a threshold of shear stress it deforms slightly and springs back, like a jelly, instead of flowing. Twenty commercial ketchups measured by Czech researchers in 2009 had static yield stresses between 25 and 65 pascals, with a mean of 45 Pa. Tilting the bottle only lets the weight of the ketchup in the narrow neck push on it, and that produces a wall stress of a few tens of pascals, the same order as the yield stress. So sometimes nothing moves at all. A firm tap or a squeeze adds the extra stress needed to break the network, and once it starts flowing, ketchup thins sharply, which is why it then tends to gush.
Is ketchup a non-Newtonian fluid?
Yes. A Newtonian fluid such as water or honey has one viscosity, so shear stress is simply proportional to shear rate, τ = ηγ̇. Ketchup breaks that rule in two ways. First, it has a yield stress, so it does not flow at all until the applied stress exceeds a threshold, typically a few tens of pascals. Second, it is shear-thinning: once flowing, its apparent viscosity falls the faster it is sheared, because the particle network breaks up and the particles align with the flow. Rheologists describe this with the Herschel–Bulkley model, τ = τ_y + Kγ̇ⁿ, where τ_y is the yield stress, K a consistency and n a flow index below 1. A 2009 study of 20 commercial ketchups found that this model fitted their behaviour well. Ketchup is also thixotropic: after vigorous shaking its structure is weakened, and it rebuilds over a few minutes at rest, so a bottle that poured easily can stick again.
Where should you tap a glass ketchup bottle?
Heinz has said the best place is the raised 57 on the neck of its glass bottle. A company spokesperson gave that advice to the Mirror in 2016, adding that only 11 per cent of people knew the trick. The physics supports tapping near the outlet. The ketchup that blocks the flow is the plug sitting in the narrow neck, and a yield-stress fluid in a pipe yields first at the wall, where the shear stress is largest, then slides out as an almost solid plug on a thin, sheared layer next to the glass. A sharp tap at the neck jolts the glass right where that plug needs to yield. University of Melbourne engineer Anthony Stickland offers a complementary method: shake the bottle with the lid on, hold it at about 45 degrees and give gentle but firm taps on the base, increasing the force until the ketchup just starts to move. Tap too hard and shear thinning turns a trickle into a flood.
Why can you run on cornstarch and water?
A dense mix of cornstarch and water, often called oobleck, is shear-thickening: the harder and faster you push it, the more it resists. Stir it slowly and the starch grains, lubricated by water, slide past one another; hit it sharply and they are forced into contact and jam into a solid-like mass. In a 2012 Nature paper, Scott Waitukaitis and Heinrich Jaeger at the University of Chicago dropped a metal rod into cornstarch suspensions and followed the response with high-speed video, embedded force sensors and X-ray imaging. Each impact launched a solidification front that turned the suspension beneath the rod into a rapidly growing jammed region, far stronger than shear thickening alone could explain. That rapidly growing solid mass soaks up momentum and pushes back hard enough to support a running foot. The support only lasts while the foot is moving fast: stand still and the grains relax, the suspension flows again, and you sink. Shear thickening is the opposite of what ketchup does, which thins as it is pushed harder.